看板 SuperJunior作者 Evan0121 (Evan)標題 Fw: [分享] 男偶像歌唱能力Best17時間 Thu Nov 17 16:29:55 2011
※ [本文轉錄自 FTIsland 看板 #1EmyF5o0 ]
看板 FTIsland作者 rgfui (小徵:)))標題 [分享] 男偶像歌唱能力Best17時間 Wed Nov 16 22:07:58 2011
1. JYJ JunSu俊秀 (Tone: 8.5, Treble: 4, Skills: 4, Volume: 4, Expressiveness
– 8.5, Total: 29.5)
2. PARAN Ace (Tone: 8, Treble: 5, Skills: 4, Volume: 4.5, Expressiveness –
7, Total: 28.5)
JYJ JaeJoong在中 (Tone: 7.5, Treble: 4.5, Skills: 4, Volume: 5,
Expressiveness – 7.5, Total: 28.5)
3. BigBang TaeYang太陽 (Tone: 8.5, Treble: 3, Skills: 4, Volume: 3.5,
Expressiveness – 8.5, Total: 27.5)
4. FT Island HongKi洪基 (Tone: 9, Treble: 3.5, Skills: 3, Volume: 4,
Expressiveness – 7, Total: 26.5)
2AM ChangMin昶旻 (Tone: 6, Treble: 5, Skills: 4.5, Volume: 4,
Expressiveness – 7, Total: 26.5)
SHINee JongHyun鐘鉉 (Tone: 7, Treble: 5, Skills: 4, Volume: 4,
Expressiveness – 6.5, Total: 26.5)
5. CNBLUE YongHwa容和 (Tone: 7.5, Treble: 3.5, Skills: 3.5,Volume:
4,Expressiveness – 7, Total: 25.5)
MBLAQ G.O (Tone: 7, Treble: 4, Skills: 4, Volume: 3.5, Expressiveness –
7, Total: 25.5)
6. SHINee Onew溫流 (Tone: 8.5, Treble: 3, Skills: 3, Volume: 3.5,
Expressiveness – 7, Total: 25)
7. SS501 YoungSaeng永生 (Tone: 7.5,Treble: 4, Skills: 3.5,Vol : 3.5,
Expressiveness– 6, Total: 24.5)
Super Junior KyuHyun圭賢 (Tone: 8,Treble: 3, Skills: 3.5,Volume:
3.5,Expressiveness – 6.5, Total: 24.5)
Super Junior YeSung藝聲(Tone: 7,Treble: 3.5,Skills: 3.5,Volume:
3.5,Expressiveness – 7, Total: 24.5)
8. 2AM JoKwon趙權 (Tone: 6, Treble: 3.5, Skills: 4, Volume: 3, Expressiveness
–7.5, Total: 24)
9. Super Junior RyeoWook厲旭 (Tone: 7.5, Treble: 3.5,Skills: 3, Volume:
3,Expressiveness – 6.5, Total: 23.5)
10.DBSK ChangMin 昌珉(Tone: 5, Treble: 5, Skills: 3, Volume: 5,
Expressiveness – 5, Total: 23)
U-Kiss SooHyun秀鉉 (Tone: 6, Treble: 4, Skills: 3, Volume: 4,
Expressiveness – 6, Total: 23)
BEAST YoSeob 耀燮(Tone: 6.5, Treble: 3.5, Skills: 3, Volume: 4,
Expressiveness – 6, Total: 23)
11. JYJ YooChun有天 (Tone: 6.5, Treble: 3.5, Skills: 3.5, Volume: 3,
Expressiveness – 6, Total: 22.5)
CNBLUE JongHyun宗泫 (Tone: 8, Treble: 2.5, Skills: 3, Vol: 2.5,
Expressiveness – 6.5, Total: 22.5)
2PM JunSu峻秀 (Tone: 6, Treble: 3.5, Skills: 3.5, Volume: 3.5,
Expressiveness – 5.5, Total: 22.5)
12.Big Bang DaeSung大聲 (Tone: 6, Treble: 3.5, Skills: 2.5, Volume: 4,
Expressiveness – 5.5, Total: 21.5)
B1A4 SanDeul燦多 (Tone: 6, Treble: 3.5, Skills: 3, Volume: 3.5,
Expressiveness – 5.5, Total: 21.5)
2AM Seulong瑟雍 (Tone: 7, Treble: 3.5, Skills: 3, Volume: 3,
Expressiveness – 5, Total: 21.5)
13.Super Junior SungMin晟敏 (Tone: 6, Treble: 3, Skills: 3, Volume: 3,
Expressiveness – 5.5, Total: 20.5)
14. SHINee TaeMin泰民 (Tone: 7.5, Treble: 2.5, Skills: 2.5, Volume: 2,
Expressiveness – 5, Total: 19.5)
15. TEENTOP Niel (Tone: 6, Treble: 2.5, Skills: 3, Volume: 2.5,
Expressiveness – 5, Total: 19)
16.DBSK YunHo允浩 (Tone: 4, Treble: 3, Skills: 2.5, Volume: 3,
Expressiveness – 3.5, Total: 16)
2AM JinWoon珍雲 (Tone: 6, Treble: 2, Skills: 2, Volume: 2,
Expressiveness – 4, Total: 16)
SHINee Key (Tone: 4, Treble: 3, Skills: 2.5, Volume: 3, Expressiveness
– 3.5, Total: 16)
17. BigBang SeungRi勝利 (Tone: 5, Treble: 1, Skills: 2, Volume: 2,
Expressiveness – 3, Total: 13)
新聞出處：NATE
轉:Daily K Pop News
==============================================================================
--
╚╝ ╚╝＊╩═╩═╩╝╚╩╩═╩══＊ ψarronrabbit
＊
Ｊong Hun Ｈong Ki Ｊae Jin Ｍin Hwan Ｓeung Hyun Ｗon Bin ＊
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.27.103.127
推 hsinne:洪基滿分!!!2F 11/16 22:16
推 keyhan:洪基第一項是最高分的欸4F 11/16 22:40
推 katy123:這個好像是韓國的聲樂專家評的，洪基音色是所有男偶像最高的9分，高音與技巧卻偏低，表示洪基還有進步的空間?6F 11/16 23:06
→ WanRyan:TONE....9分!!!!!8F 11/16 23:30
推 yamicoo:我也給滿分，有問過幾個不喜歡洪基高音的都說是太爆了
見人見智拉，我喜歡有活力的聲音，他們喜歡修飾圓潤的
李洪基快去加強你的技巧拉XDDDDD11F 11/17 00:06
推 liwhere:洪基的聲音非常特別阿14F 11/17 00:13
推 vovopig24:其實...可以不需要說其他人聲音普通的話唷~
畢竟這裡不是只有pri才會來晃15F 11/17 00:29
→ rgfui:每個人各有各的特色~唱歌實力都不同:)17F 11/17 00:33
推 liwhere:感謝vovo提醒拉~~原po晚點看到可以幫我修掉推文嗎~~
謝啦!!!!18F 11/17 01:01
推 vv200242000:好前面:)但我覺得在真歌聲也很好聽!!希望以後看到他在排行上!!20F 11/17 09:44
推 fionaliu:真驕傲呀^^ 洪基歌聲辨識度真的很高!!
但有時洪基太嗨時會用力過度，希望他好好保護嗓子啊:)22F 11/17 09:51
※ 編輯: rgfui 來自: 114.27.100.58 (11/17 13:44)
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
※ 轉錄者: Evan0121 (140.126.34.171), 時間: 11/17/2011 16:29:55
推 fish8322:這種穿鑿附會說是什麼公司內部啊 或者聲樂家的評論
如果沒有真憑實據 附上評論的人名的話 都是小道吧
我也可以自己寫一寫 然後發在網路上 然後說是上層評論1F 11/17 16:35
推 arazu:我倒覺得評論蠻有趣的，分了很多細項，不過因為排版關係有點眼花，大雲哥情緒渲染方面的分數排得上前幾名，柳物音色辨識度也頗高，硬要挑的話只有想知道技巧方面如何評分，看看這種多人的評分也不錯，在上面的真的都是實力派啊(大拇指)4F 11/17 16:42
推 illbe:(我喜歡弘基也喜歡圭賢) 覺得圭賢的聲音很耐聽.很舒服的聲音不過...還是是曲風的關係^^a 話說 圭賢聲音真好阿...8F 11/17 16:57
推 arazu:還有Volume是拿分貝計嗎XDDDDDD10F 11/17 17:07
推 breakaway:容初丁比藝聲圭賢高了兩名耶?我真是被他的表相給騙了T^T11F 11/17 17:13
推 egodelphi:容初丁名次高的嚇到我了XDD 不管怎樣KRY還是心目中最高!12F 11/17 17:27
推 sinon211407:鄭女婿蠻會唱的啊 不過再怎麼說還是自己家KRY最好XD13F 11/17 17:44
→ Marcia621:看到晟敏上榜好開心+6 樓上ㄢㄤ不分XDD
LINYUTIN@HOTMAIL.CO.UK20F 11/18 09:53
→ grace172:樓上是廣告嗎? 沒有確實出處 轉錄的意義不大22F 11/18 12:57
推 Marcia621:天啊我為什麼會貼上自己的EMAIL= =好糗喔 能不能拜託原原PO幫我刪掉... 糗斃了天啊23F 11/18 13:22
--
※ 同主題文章:
Fw: [分享] 男偶像歌唱能力Best17
11-17 16:29 Evan0121.