---

來源：
nascompares.com/2025/06/02/i-went-to-synology-hq-and-asked-about-hard-drives

重點就是作者拜訪了Synology HQ，重點擺在為什麼25年開始的個人用NAS要限用自家硬碟
細節大家應該都不太想聽，重點就是下面這兩段


該文引用了Synology Regional Sales Manager的文並提到確認第三方硬碟清單會在未來
提供

The article also mentioned that Synology-certified drives undergo over 7,000
hours of testing, and systems using those drives reportedly experience 40%
fewer failures than those using uncertified media. Additionally, Synology
claims that severe storage anomalies have dropped by up to 88% in systems
following its compatibility policy. Although Chang confirmed that third-party
compatibility may expand in the future, it will only do so under strict
adherence to Synology’s internal benchmarks. These statements align with
Synology’s position during the HQ tour, further emphasizing a shift toward a
closed, highly controlled ecosystem that prioritizes consistent performance
over hardware flexibility.

然後作者並未提出證據或具體來源但提供了下面的訊息

My biggest issue with all this is that, almost certainly, we are going to see
Seagate, WD, Toshiba and more slow (slooooooooowly) appear on the
compatibility lists for a number of the 2025 generation of devices over the
coming months. So, what was all this for? The PR damage and likely early
sales damage of the Synolgoy 2025 Series because of this change of support I
would estimate is going to be pretty substantial – and all the reports and
reactions to this online are not going to go away as soon as a Seagate
Ironwolf or WD Red drive appears on the support lists. Also, Synology work on
these devices for a very, very long time before launch – why is all this
happening now – and not before launch. The cynic in me wants to just assume
it was pure profitability and that Synology want to maximize profits, and if
when this does begin to U-Trun ,that the brand can say that it was the plan
all along. But whether that is true or not, the damage to the brand in the
eyes of a substantial % of their long term fans is notable, and with many
more players in the market (UniFi, QNAP, UGREEN and more) launching new
products in Q3 and Q4 – is this all going to be a gamble by the brand that
ends up costing them more than just leaving the support status quo where it
was? Only time will tell.



這樣看來925+過年就可以買了(？

--
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 118.169.26.54 (臺灣)
※ 作者: rotalume 2025-06-23 13:28:31
※ 文章代碼(AID): #1eMEO1g6 (PC_Shopping)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/PC_Shopping/M.1750656513.A.A86.html