作者 icemaydays (天若有情)標題 [新聞] 大熱天免費提供冰水給路人卻被罰款 亞利時間 Tue Jul 22 02:33:34 2025
大熱天免費提供冰水給路人卻被罰款 亞利桑納男槓上HOA
https://yhoo.it/44Tnq0n
Arizona man’s HOA keeps fining him $100 for giving out water in heat — lawyer
for HOA explains. Do you agree?
Rudro Chakrabarti
Mon, July 14, 2025 at 1:25 AM GMT+8
4 min read
David Martin and the water cooler he places on his property for his neighbors fr
ee of charge.
David Martin and the water cooler he places on his property for his neighbors fr
ee of charge.
David Martin of Goodyear, Arizona, says he just wanted to help his neighbors sta
y hydrated during triple-digit temperatures — but now he’s being fined for it
by his homeowners association.
Martin has been placing a cooler filled with free bottled water near the sidewal
k outside his home since May of 2020.
“It’s for the kids, the delivery drivers, the couple holding hands walking dow
n the street,” Martin told local outlet KPHO. “It’s for the little kid who ha
s to walk his dog in the heat.”
ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
In 2022, the Canyon Trails HOA and its management company FirstService Residenti
al, gave him a warning for his cooler, but then followed up with an apology lett
er.
"At that point, I thought it was over and done, and we wouldn't have any problem
s ever again until May of this year," Martin shared with local outlet KYMA in 20
24. Then in May of 2024 he received his first fine for $50, eventually escalatin
g to multiple citations for $100. Ever since then Martins has been receiving fin
es of $100 whenever he puts out his cooler when it gets hot out.
He claims the fines are unfair — and dangerous — in a state where heat has alr
eady killed dozens this year.
Don't miss
I'm 49 years old and have nothing saved for retirement — what should I do? Don'
t panic. Here are 6 of the easiest ways you can catch up (and fast)
Thanks to Jeff Bezos, you can now become a landlord for as little as $100 — and
no, you don't have to deal with tenants or fix freezers. Here's how
Want an extra $1,300,000 when you retire? Dave Ramsey says this 7-step plan ‘wo
rks every single time’ to kill debt, get rich in America — and that ‘anyone’
can do it
ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
“Here we are in July, the hottest day of the year, and we are still talking abo
ut a water cooler with free cold water,” Martin said. “It’s ridiculous that t
hey are adding violations to a total that’s not going to get paid, because I’m
giving out free water.”
An attorney for the Canyon Trails HOA released a statement to KPHO last year say
ing:
"The association does not object to a resident providing free water bottles to t
he community; however, the community's rules do not allow a resident to advertis
e water bottle distribution from a portable ice chest, located next to their gar
age that is visible from neighboring property."
A legal battle to follow
After months of mounting fines, Martin launched a petition to recall three HOA b
oard members. He claims it received over 100 signatures.
ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
According to 12News, a special meeting was held on Thursday Jul. 10 where 190 ou
t of 210 votes cast supported removing the board members. But the fight wasn't o
ver.
本來想貼紐時
廣告太多了
簡單來說
因為亞利桑納真的太熱了
於是這男的在自家車庫免費發放冰水給路人
結果這行為被裁定
違反不得在公開地點存放物品的規定
他被美國社區類似管委會的組織HOA
起先罰款50元他拒繳
結果被連續每個月加100美元
本來這事也蠻平常的
但偏偏美國的HOA臭名昭著
有的HOA甚至連你家花叢多高都要規定
車庫門不能打開超過15分鐘
超過1公分或超過1分鐘都要罰到你怕
而且各種奇怪理由收錢
“煩”不勝”煩”
結果就是直接引起眾怒
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 111.82.67.21 (臺灣)
※ 作者: icemaydays 2025-07-22 02:33:34
※ 文章代碼(AID): #1eVeW0bs (Gossiping)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Gossiping/M.1753122816.A.976.html
※ 編輯: icemaydays (111.82.67.21 臺灣), 07/22/2025 02:36:12
推 OPPAISuki: 說好的美國自由人權呢?1F 36.225.166.68 台灣 07/22 02:36
→ nikewang: 美國說自由也不自由 像想買某社區房子的話 還要像管委會一樣的社區居民投票同2F 210.105.80.250 南韓 07/22 02:37
推 lianli1024: HOA跟隔壁大媽一樣整天搞事4F 111.250.59.19 台灣 07/22 02:38
→ nikewang: 意才讓你搬進來住5F 210.105.80.250 南韓 07/22 02:38
推 O10lOl01O: 管成這樣哪招?6F 118.171.133.225 台灣 07/22 02:39
→ kaodio: 上法院啊7F 118.160.79.85 台灣 07/22 02:41
※ 編輯: icemaydays (111.82.67.21 臺灣), 07/22/2025 02:48:48
推 cmc563: 賈伯斯當年在車庫創業怎麼沒被罰錢8F 101.0.239.144 台灣 07/22 03:07
→ reallurker: 十九歲不能喝酒但是可以買槍9F 141.70.30.222 德國 07/22 03:09
→ haha98: 就HOA搞得阿 老梗了10F 223.137.203.47 台灣 07/22 03:27
→ icecubes: 非要讓人覺得這世界好心沒好報11F 223.140.29.184 台灣 07/22 03:32
推 guppys2005: 要是到時喝水出問題HOA絕對會被告 不要懷疑美國的律師12F 72.159.77.63 美國 07/22 04:10
噓 louisnight: 台灣沒HOA 鄰居吵都吵死你14F 129.219.8.116 美國 07/22 04:21
→ eva19452002: 40年前，台灣還有所謂的奉茶放在門口供路過的民眾喝15F 118.232.62.188 台灣 07/22 05:10
推 alotofjeff: 中共有城管，美國有HOA17F 114.137.168.237 台灣 07/22 06:36
--