---

最近台灣低生育率也引發reddit網友關注 看到2篇討論
第一篇是網友在新聞下面的留言 https://reurl.cc/6bRLxM

1. Heartfelt congratulations from South Korea for taking over the championship
南韓網友發來衷心祝賀，感謝台灣接手了這個（倒數第一的）冠軍寶座。

https://i.meee.com.tw/EuBHo0R.png
2. Wait, so Beijing doesn’t even need to invade. They can just wait.
等等，所以北京根本不需要入侵，他們只要坐著等就好。

2-1. If I were China, I'd scrap the 2027 invasion plan and continue to build
up military tensions to lock up Taiwan's fiscal budget towards military
spending rather than social welfare. Taiwan will soon have to deal with
increased expenditures for elderly care + young people leaving the country
due to insanely high tax rates and low opportunities. They will slowly (or
rapidly) crumble from within.


3. The most educated countries tend to have the least amount of kids
教育程度越高的國家，孩子通常生得越少。

4. "Taiwan's working hours ranked the sixth-longest globally in 2022" "The
latest World Inequality Report shows a major wealth gap in Taiwan, with the
richest 10% holding 60% of the wealth." "in Taiwan, the minimum wage is less
than 50% of the "living wage"" And the constant threat of invasion…
I’d be pulling out too


第二篇則是有網友問 為什麼台灣從未實施一胎化政策，生育率卻比中國還低？
https://i.meee.com.tw/R9ywUUF.png https://reurl.cc/oK3ZAM

大家都說中國超低的總和生育率主要是因為一胎化政策。但從未有過這種政策的台灣，
現在生育率甚至比中國還低，還是全球最低之一。 我也發現，許多華人背景的社會


下面回覆
1. Taiwan was richer, earlier and thus underwent the demographic transition
earlier, bringing it in line with other highly developed countries.  China's
one child policy just accelerated its own demographic transition to earlier
than would be predicted from GDP alone.
台灣更早富裕，因此更早經歷了人口轉型，這與其他高度發達國家一致。中國的一胎化政
策只是加速了它自己的人口轉型，讓轉型時間比單純看 GDP 預測的還要早發生。

2. A few reasons. 1) The price of housing is a bit insane and Taiwanese
usually won't have kids without owning a house/flat (apartment) 2) Taiwanese
rarely have kids outside of marriage. 3)We are a rich, urbanised country 4)
the governments have not exactly helped although they pretend to eg for child
care we have a stupid sort of lottery for the public kindergarten and if you
don't get that then the cost of child care is high 5) we tend to work long
hours 6) we are a relatively free society with more women's rights than most
places in Asia so people can choose to be openly gay more easily than in
other countries or for women to not marry etc. 7) the two groups with the
highest birth rate (Aboriginals and immigrants) are relatively small portion
of the population.
房價瘋狂： 台灣人通常在沒買房/公寓的情況下不考慮生小孩。
非婚生子女極少： 台灣人很少在婚姻之外生小孩。
高度城市化： 我們是一個富裕且高度城市化的國家。
政府沒幫上忙： 政府雖然假裝在幫忙，但例如托育，公立幼兒園竟然要抽籤，如果沒抽
到，育兒成本就極高。
長工時： 我們工作時間很長。
權利提升： 我們是相對自由的社會，女性權利比亞洲多數地方好，所以人們可以更自由
地選擇出櫃、或者女性選擇不婚。
特定族群佔比小： 生育率最高的兩個群體（原住民和新移民）佔總人口比例相對較小。

3. Taiwan has a strong education system and insane work culture, people are
smart enough to avoid unwanted pregnancies, are expected to plan their careers
thoroughly, and work long hours. That's not conducive to a high fertility rate
台灣有強大的教育體系和瘋狂的加班文化。人們聰明到懂得避開非計畫懷孕，被期待要徹
底規畫職涯，而且工時又長，這完全不利於提高生育率。

4. Citizen here. It’s the housing price. When most can’t afford a place
with 10 years of full salary and yet the society expects you to own it to be
a good enough spouse. People start to think “what if I refuse to work like
 an ant for riches and just for myself instead?”.
在地國民路過：就是房價。 當多數人領了 10 年全額薪水都買不起房，
社會卻期望你要先買房才算是個及格的配偶。

western european countries, fairly low population density and affordable
housing everywhere outside of the largest cities.
確實如此。 這就是為什麼法國表現得比其他西歐國家好——人口密度較低，
且除了大城市以外，房價都是負擔得起的。


備註
紅到全球的低生育率 真的是台灣之光

----
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 118.160.37.230 (臺灣)
※ 作者: usnavyseal 2026-01-12 17:34:20
※ 文章代碼(AID): #1fPC0VHg (Gossiping)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Gossiping/M.1768210463.A.46A.html